4 Lies You've Been Told About Dividends
A Guest Post From Compounding Dividends
Today, I’m excited to share an excellent guest post from my friend TJ at Compounding Dividends.
You can learn plenty from his writings, and his thoughts and beliefs on dividend investing closely align with mine!
I enjoy following his work on Substack and X.
Enjoy the below writing from Compounding Dividends!
- Dividendology
Dividends are a powerful way to build wealth.
Yet lies and bad information about dividends persist.
Let’s break everything down and help you to make great investing decisions.
Separating dividend fact from fiction can make a huge difference in the performance of your portfolio over time.
Let’s take a look at four of the biggest lies you've been told about dividends - and show you what the smartest investors already know.
Lie #1: "Dividends Waste Capital That Could Be Reinvested"
Reality: Strong companies can grow AND pay dividends
Profitable companies often generate more cash than they can effectively reinvest.
Source: Finchat
Walmart has raised its dividend payment for 52 years in a row while:
Investing heavily in research and development (R&D) to enhance its e-commerce capabilities, logistics, and in-store technologies
Regularly pursuing strategic acquisitions to expand its product offerings and geographic reach, such as the acquisition of Jet.com in 2016
Maintaining a healthy balance sheet
Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway earns $776 million in dividends from Coca-Cola alone:
Studies show dividend-paying companies often have:
Better capital discipline
Stronger cash flow management
Higher quality earnings
The idea that paying a dividend always comes at the expense of the growth of the company is simply not true.
Lie #2: "Dividends Are Just Bribes for Investors"
Reality: Dividends reflect business strength and shareholder alignment
When you buy shares of a publicly traded company, you become a minority owner of the business.
Dividends are your share of the profits.
What’s the point in owning a company if you never get to access the profit it generates?
“The prime purpose of a business corporation is to pay dividends regularly and, presumably, to increase the rate as time goes on.” - Benjamin Graham
Regular dividends signal:
Sustainable earnings
Strong cash flow
Management confidence
Historical fact: Dividend-paying stocks outperformed non-payers by 1.5% annually from 1972-2022
Dividends aren’t a bribe when:
The company has excess cash
Growth opportunities are funded
The balance sheet is healthy
Dividends are a way for strong companies to align incentives and distribute profits to the owners.
Lie #3: "Dividends Create Tax Problems"
Reality: Tax are the result of making money, and their impact can be managed
Taxes happen when you make money, whether through dividends or other means.
Trying to avoid taxes by avoiding dividends is just a bad strategy.
Here’s the return of the S&P 500 considering only the price versus the total return if you would have reinvested your dividends.
While buybacks are even more tax efficient than dividends, the Dividend Aristocrats still outperform the S&P when a 20% tax is assumed:
Taxes and laws vary around the world, but there are multiple ways to manage taxes:
Tax-advantaged accounts
Dividend reinvestment plans (DRIPs) allow you to reinvest without actually receiving the cash
Accumulating ETFs exist that reinvest the dividends received instead of distributing them
Taxes are necessary when you make money. Dividend payers still tend to outperform, even when taxes are included. Rules vary around the world. Know what the implications are for you and what your options are to manage taxes instead of avoiding dividends altogether.
Lie #4: "Dividends Dilute Shareholder Value"
Reality: The "dividend fallacy" misunderstands total return
The dividend fallacy refers to the misconception that dividends are "free" money for shareholders.
Fans of this argument like to say that when a company pays a dividend, its stock price typically decreases by the same amount, meaning shareholders do not gain additional value.
Yes, in theory, the stock price drops by dividend amount, but theory also states that it first rises:
This all assumes that both the markets and investors and are perfectly rational and efficient, when in reality we know that they are not.
That’s why in the real world dividend growers tend to outperform, as we’ve already shown you.
Very few dividend investors focus only on the dividend component
Most look at the total return.
This combines both the change in the investment's value and any income it produces.
It gives you the full picture of how much an investment has earned (or lost) over a certain period.
While we like consistent and growing dividend payments, we also want our capital to grow.
You can think of dividends like:
Harvesting crops while keeping the farm
Regular income from a rental property
They can provide a lot of income. You can even live off them in retirement, but they’re not the whole picture.
Bottom Line
Dividends are a powerful tool for building long-term wealth.
When quality companies maintain sustainable payout ratios while funding growth and maintaining strong balance sheets, dividends represent real value for shareholders.
Smart investors know: It's not about choosing between growth or dividends.
The best companies deliver both.
That’s it for today!
Here’s what you need to remember:
When companies maintain sustainable payout ratios, fund attractive growth, and maintain strong balance sheets, they can deliver income + capital appreciation
Dividends make up a significant portion of historical returns from stocks, and dividend payers tend to outperform
P.S.
I’ve put together a special offer for you.
If you want access to my Dividend Investor’s Toolkit, you can get it with the button below.
Here’s what’s inside:
Compounding Dividends’ Guide to Dividend Stock Analysis: Analyze dividend stocks like a professional with this guide
The Dividend Investor's Checklist: Make sure you're thorough in your analysis with this checklist
A Case Study in Consistent Income: 5 stocks on my 2025 short list that show you how to think about assembling your portfolio.
Dividend Aristocrats Spreadsheet: All 66 companies in the S&P 500 that have increased their dividend payments for at least 25 years - a great place to find ideas
 | A guest post by
|
Great post guys! Excellent and simple argument for what dividends represent. I find myself pushing back all the time on dividend haters, which is so crazy because as mentioned, it’s one of the core reasons and benefits of stock ownership.
Thanks for having me!